Rounding up or down?

If you're looking at preferred parking (SSc4.3) for and you determine that your project needs 4.15 LEV parking spaces, how many should you provide, 4 or 5? While this is a relatively harmless difference (one more sign probably won't break the bank), the difference between 1 or 2 showers (SSc4.2) might be more of an issue in an small office building.
I wasn't sure about this answer until I noticed that the credit templates solved the answer for me. One tenth of a shower is a full shower, and rounding up, even when the numbers would typically be rounded down is the norm.
Take the following example:
5% of 180 FTE is 9.00000 secure bicycle storage spaces require. If we add one more FTE, then 5% of 181 is 9.05, which in most minds would round down to 9. In this case however, the LEED credit calculator rounds the number up to 10 required spaces:

3 comments:

  1. Oh man. This shit totally gets me off.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm working on a LEED-CS v2.0 project and when I type in the FTE information in the SSc4.2 Alternative Transportation: Bicycle Storage & Changing Rooms - Option 2, I get all sorts of wonkiness.

    I have a 320,000 SF building with a total FTE of 1482. This breaks down into 1389 being allocated to the first 300,000 SF and 93 being allocated to the remaining 20,000SF. When I do the calcs I get 7.4 showers and 42.14 Bike storage spaces. Using the rounding up rule of LEED presented in this post, I would assume the template would have spit out 8 showers and 43 bike storage spaces. Instead it spit out - 7 showers and 45 bike storage spaces!!!! It is enough to make you think you are going crazy.

    If anyone re-runs this calc and finds that I am making (most likely an excel error). Please let me know!

    thanks!

    ReplyDelete

Though Real Life LEED reserves the right to remove any and all comments at any time, in general I only remove posts if:

1. I feel like you're trying to sell more than trying to help. I don't mind if you share some website or product you own or market if it genuinely adds to the discussion. (19 posts removed so far)

2. You're posting as someone other than yourself. (0 posts removed so far)

3. You're post is in poor taste (racist, sexist, bullyish, etc.) as defined by me, Real Life LEED. (0 posts removed so far)

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.